Season 03

Methodologies of Contemporary Art Photography

Centered on the works of Jeff Wall, the Bechers, Thomas Demand, Thomas Ruff, and Martha Rosler, this season analyzes the creative methods of contemporary art photography. Each lesson is organized around one question: why did the artist choose this way of shooting, what did this approach change, and how does it constitute the meaning of the work?

Season 3: Methodologies of Contemporary Art Photography course poster

Lesson 01

Jeff Wall: Pioneering a Labor Model of Figural Photography

Contemporary Art Photography: Methods and Practice course illustration
© Jeff Wall

"Labour" is our key word for approaching Jeff Wall. Jeff Wall can be said to hold the highest artistic standing of any contemporary photographer. But could merely appropriating paintings from art history, merely constructing forms, be enough to sustain his practice at such a level? Of course not. In earlier courses we explained Wall's photographs in terms of "absorption," but that is not enough to explain why his practice matters so much as to hold its current place in art history. I will use the term "figural photography" to describe Jeff Wall's practice and place it within the realm of the production and reproduction of labor relations, attempting to reveal that Wall's turn to staged photography and cinematic photography is rooted in his effort to restore the "bodily sense" of artistic creation that conceptual-art photography had stripped away, and, through restoring this bodily sense, to establish an entirely different model of photographic labor. After him, this model has become the mainstream of contemporary photographic production. We will explain the constitution of this new labor model, as well as its counterpart, another mode of creation—nonfigural photography.

Lesson 02

From Repetition to Typology: Visualizing Social Abstraction

Contemporary Art Photography: Methods and Practice course illustration
© Hilla Becher und Bernd Becher

Bernd and Hilla Becher are probably among the most discussed names in the history of photography, yet what is so remarkable about those almost indistinguishable water towers and cooling towers? Why do they always appear in groups and pairs, why do they look at once detached and precise, and why did the Bechers photograph, of all things, the industrial remains of the Ruhr? The usual explanations draw a straight line from historical fact to the notion that "this is art," and they explain almost nothing about these basic questions. In this lecture I will hold fast to the form of repetition, situating the Bechers after Ed Ruscha's Twentysix Gasoline Stations and before the New Topographics. To answer why repetition could become a method of social critique, we must first understand space. Space is produced, and from the 1950s onward the state and capital jointly determined its shape, a condition we call "social abstraction." Once capital withdrew, the Ruhr's fixed capital was reduced to a "dead landscape," and the wilderness of Ansel Adams could no longer serve as a ground for critique. It was in precisely this situation that Ruscha first brought spatial abstraction into photography as a formal problem, and repetition became the very decentered visual experience of that era. The Bechers pushed it to its limit, producing what Rosalind Krauss calls the "grid." Their work internalizes social abstraction in visual form while using formal rigor to resist the fate of these objects, which faced complete erasure.

Lesson 03

Saturated Intention and the Uncanny: Spatial Abstraction in Thomas Demand's Photography

Contemporary Art Photography: Methods and Practice course illustration
© Thomas Demand

With Thomas Demand, the question left by the previous lecture becomes even sharper. He does not even photograph real spaces, only paper models he builds by hand. How, then, can photography still intervene in the production of abstract space? Unlike Andreas Gursky, who encompasses abstract space through panoramic views and digital post-production, Demand continues the mode of studio labor pioneered by Jeff Wall. He starts from media images, traces their sources, translates the scenes into full-scale paper models, and then photographs them. His best-known work, Corridor, is based on the since-demolished Milwaukee apartment building of the serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer. From this corridor to the other interiors he has reconstructed, the images seem ordinary and cool at first glance, but on closer inspection something is wrong everywhere: the familiar scenes have lost the traces left by everyday use. I will use Freud's concept of the "uncanny" to explain this feeling. What it is closest to is in fact doubt: the return of the familiar calls into question the entire order in which we find ourselves, and even knowing in advance that these are paper models does not dispel the unease. Régis Durand's notion of the "saturation of intentionality" identifies its source. There is nothing in the image but the artist's intention, which precisely inverts what John Berger called photography's "weak intentionality." The question of space has always been who occupies it, under what conditions, and for what purposes. Demand has us sense the workings of power within it rather than revealing them, and this questioning itself carries a quite strong political charge.

Lesson 04

Face, Identity, and Archive: Thomas Ruff's Portrait Photographs

Contemporary Art Photography: Methods and Practice course illustration
© Thomas Ruff

"Archive" is our key word for approaching Thomas Ruff. It should be pointed out first that Ruff's typological practice is fundamentally different from that of the Bechers—in fact, it goes in the opposite direction: the Bechers invoke the form of the archive, whereas Ruff interrogates the function of the archive. By examining Ruff's Portraits series, I will try to show why only by recognizing the archival nature of Ruff's photographs can we explain genetically how his portraits are constructed: Why use the passport format? Why use composite portraits? Why such meticulous staging? Why photograph the faces so sharply and vividly? "Photographic archives" as an entry point is the key to explaining the reasons for these forms and their effects.

Lesson 05

The Female Body and Domestic Labor: Martha Rosler's Photomontage

Contemporary Art Photography: Methods and Practice course illustration
© Martha Rosler

"Body" is our key word for approaching Martha Rosler. Martha Rosler is a typical case of an artist who is highly renowned abroad yet virtually unknown in China, and she is often mentioned in the same breath as Allan Sekula. Even setting aside the feminist lineage, Rosler's work still has great critical value. I try to seize on the technique of "photomontage" that Rosler uses to dismantle the process by which the female body is "produced" (especially "produced" through photography), and to further explain Rosler's exploration of the binary category of women's "body–identity": Why the female body? What does it mean for the female body to be placed in domestic space? How does this placement of the body affect the consciousness of "identity"?

References

瓦尔特·本雅明. 作为生产者的作者[M]. 河南大学出版社,2014.

弗里德里希·尼采. 悲剧的诞生[M]. 孙周兴,译. 商务印书馆,2017.

迈克尔·弗雷德. 艺术与物性(论文与评论集)[M]. 张晓剑、沈语冰,译. 江苏美术出版社,2013.

大卫·哈维. 巴黎城记(现代性之都的诞生)[M]. 黄煜文,译. 广西师范大学出版社,2010.

罗莎琳·克劳斯. 前卫的原创性及其他现代主义神话[M]. 周文姬、路珏,译. 江苏凤凰美术出版社,2015.

克莱尔·毕晓普. 人造地狱(参与式艺术与观看者政治学)[M]. 中国美术学院出版社.

约翰·伯格. 观看之道[M]. 戴行钺,译. 广西师范大学出版社,2015.

汉斯·贝尔廷. 脸的历史[M]. 史竞舟,译. 北京大学出版社,2017.

约翰·塔格. 表征的重负(论摄影与历史)[M]. 周韵,译. 重庆大学出版社,2018.

艾丽丝·玛丽恩·杨. 像女孩那樣丢球(論女性身體經驗)[M]. 何定照譯. 商周出版,2007. 繁體中文版.

列维纳斯. 总体与无限(论外在性)[M]. 朱刚,译. 北京大学出版社,2016.

西蒙娜·德·波伏瓦. 第二性(第二卷 实际体验)[M]. 郑克鲁,译. 上海译文出版社,2011.

西蒙娜·德·波伏瓦. 第二性(第一卷 事实与神话)[M]. 上海译文出版社,2011.

Dimitrakaki, Angela. Labour Divides: Care Politics and Strategies of Solidarity in the Art Field. Routledge, 2023.

Fried, Michael. Why Photography Matters as Art as Never Before. Yale University Press, 2008.

Krauss, Rosalind E. The Originality of the Avant-Garde and Other Modernist Myths. The MIT Press, 1985.

Lévi-Strauss, Claude. The Elementary Structures of Kinship. Eyre & Spottiswoode, 1969.

Roberts, John. Photography and Its Violations. Columbia University Press, 2014.

Roberts, John. The Art of Interruption: Realism, Photography and the Everyday. Manchester University Press, 1998.

Sekula, Allan. “The Body and the Archive.” October 39, 1986, pp. 3–64.

Wall, Jeff. Photographs. Walther König, 2003.

Yanagisako, Sylvia Junko, and Carol Delaney, editors. Naturalizing Power: Essays in Feminist Cultural Analysis. Routledge, 1995.

Instructor