Lesson 01
Overview: How to Appreciate Art Photography?

You can read every history of photography on the market until the pages fall apart and still be unable to answer a simple question: did Jeff Wall produce a masterpiece just because he borrowed from Manet? Could an ordinary person really never take a photograph like this in a lifetime? I want to move the question one step back. Before asking "Why is it valuable?", ask "Why do I find it hard to understand?" The first question is about the photograph; the second is about one's own sensory experience. The keyword of this lecture is "intuition." Drawing on Husserl's epoché, we will temporarily bracket preconceived judgments about art, masters and meaning, return to "how all of this presents itself to me," and answer through description. We will practice on Wall's photograph of a ventriloquist at a birthday party: the picture's tones are warm, yet the children are not smiling, and the perspective lines of the walls, carpet and furniture are out of alignment with one another. This is precisely how unease is produced. Mimic, in turn, shows that intuition and social issues are not at odds: racism takes concrete form in the picture as a casual gesture, and what the viewer experiences is how it enters everyday life. Starting from these concrete experiences of looking, we will then turn to Foucault's "discursive practice" to ask under what conditions photography comes to be recognized as art, while guarding against mistaking origins for explanations.
Lesson 02
What Is Lost Between the World and the Photograph?

You climb a mountain for hours, finally see the sunrise, photograph it and post it on WeChat Moments, only for others to see an utterly unremarkable tourist snapshot. What exactly is lost between the world and the photograph? I will answer with Heidegger's analysis of "worldhood" in Being and Time. The world we inhabit is not a collection of things. It is a network of meaning made up of a "referential totality" (Verweisung) in which pieces of equipment refer to one another, a world we have always already understood through our concernful dealings. The photograph's frame severs these relations of reference and erases the accumulation of time on which feeling depends. This is what Sekula calls "semantic poverty." Yet the photograph itself is also in the world, and the relations it severs must be understood together with the relations it establishes. Following Barad's line of thought, the cut of the frame can be understood as an "agential cut": in excluding, it constitutes new relations, just as Saigon Execution re-entered the world as part of the war. The second half of the lecture takes Martha Rosler's The Bowery in two inadequate descriptive systems as its example. She excluded the drunks from the frame, photographing only storefronts, iron grilles and empty bottles, and paired them with slang terms for drunkenness. Through this arrangement, the way poverty is naturalized in discourse itself becomes the object of looking.
Lesson 03
How to Photograph the Everyday: Starting from Stephen Shore

People who study Shore often begin with the intricate formal relations in Beverly Boulevard & La Brea Avenue. Yet after taking that photograph, Shore felt that he had merely been using a seventeenth-century, Claude Lorrain–style composition to interpret a twentieth-century street corner, so he went back the next day and took it again. This lecture starts from the difference between these two photographs and, drawing on my many years of familiarity with Shore's work and my acquaintance with him, moves from the simple to the more demanding through three keywords. The first is "structure." Compositional rules such as the rule of thirds exist prior to whatever is photographed and have nothing to do with the experience on the spot; what structure has to deal with is how to convey, on a flat plane, the experience of being in three-dimensional space. Moreover, structure must be transparent: in Shore's words, a photograph should convey the experience of seeing something, not the experience of composing a photograph. The second is "attention," and I will draw on Husserl's intentionality to understand what Shore means when he says that attention is life. The third, and the most elusive, is the "mental image." We will conduct a few viewing experiments and then, through Shore's family photographs and Walker Evans's gas station, see how a photographer's attention can make space deep or flatten it into collage. As Shore himself puts it, he takes pictures in order to live better.
Lesson 04
Why Do Some Photographs Sell for So Much?

When a sparse, seemingly dull photograph sells at auction for several million dollars, many people's first reaction is "It's not worth it." This reaction takes two things for granted: that price is objective, and that price equals artistic quality. This lecture sets out to dismantle both assumptions. We will first distinguish valuation, done for the purposes of a transaction, from appraisal, done for legal, insurance and tax purposes, and then look at how fair market value, retail replacement value and liquidation value can yield strikingly different figures for the same work depending on its use. For large-format works such as those of Wall and Gursky, framing, crating, shipping, insurance and storage are themselves part of the price. More crucially, what the market buys is the work's identity, including its provenance, publication history, exhibition record and certificate of authenticity. Cattelan's Comedian pushed this to the extreme: what was actually sold was the certificate of authenticity. I will also argue against the lazy habit of crying "money laundering" at the sight of a high price; whether a financial act is lawful and whether the art market is legitimate are questions belonging to two different systems. Only by understanding these concrete conditions of pricing can we go on to discuss what relationship actually exists between artistic quality and market price.
Lesson 05
The Question of Scale in Photography: The Tableau Form

Michael Fried summarized four features of the "tableau form": large scale, made for the wall; distance from the viewer; borrowing from the pictorial tradition; and the pursuit of unity over fragments, with "absorption" set against "theatricality." These four points appear tightly interlinked, but my judgment is that there is no necessary logical relationship among them, and the first in particular does not stand up to scrutiny against the history of photography. For a long time, photographs were small. It was precisely because they were small that they could enter the Fogg Art Museum and Wölfflin's double-projection teaching, and could be placed in albums and set into lockets. Yet enlarged photographs entered exhibition halls as early as the late nineteenth century, and by the 1930s photomurals covering entire walls had appeared. Treating the change in scale after the 1970s as a point of rupture is a teleological narrative. We therefore need to return to the "tableau" itself. Since Diderot, it has referred to a geometry of viewing that makes the viewer stop and judge. Fried shifted the emphasis to the relationship between work and viewer, whereas Chevrier, when he proposed the concept, valued fragmentation, openness and contradiction. Following Chevrier's thread, we will see how staged photography uses distanciation to expose the non-identity of reality and thereby make statements about the world.
Lesson 06
How Are AI Images Changing Photography?

AI-generated images are convincing enough to pass for the real thing, and so some have declared that "photography is dead." Behind this judgment lie two confusions: first, equating photography with photographs; second, treating photographs as pure expressions of style. This lecture addresses two questions. First, why AI-generated images cannot be called photographs. If we judge only by "whether it looks real," their close relative is in fact machine-generated hyperrealist painting. The force of a photograph comes from somewhere else: our belief in its indexicality has long since sunk into what Peirce calls "collateral knowledge." Kim Phúc's Vietnam War photograph cannot be denied because of this body of knowledge and cross-verification from multiple sources. Deepfake sexual rumors still cause harm even after being debunked for the same reason: our collateral knowledge is still the old one. Second, whether AI has creativity. I believe it is pointless to ask this question in isolation; we should first ask whether AI has already changed the boundaries of creativity. From Niépce's early photographic experiments to the manually adjusted Blue Marble and the rotated composition of Earthrise, photography has never been merely human vision. The real disagreement lies in who bears purposiveness, and from there I will turn to distributed "nonhuman creativity."
Lesson 07
Should "Old Masters" and "Sugar-Water Photos" Be Criticized?

On Chinese social media, "anti-saccharine warriors" can never see a saccharine photo without a few sneering remarks, their reasons being roughly that such photos are low in taste, homogeneous, thoughtless and fake in what they depict. I want to offer a different voice, one that may offend some people. Saccharine photos are indeed poor in form, but judgments of taste and the legitimacy of existence are two different matters. Photography has long been a practice that mediates everyday life, and a veteran enthusiast lugging a camera and lying in wait for three hours is having an experience too. If one sets a certain kind of high-art photography as the ultimate ideal for all practice and then uses it to strafe the people taking pictures, the problem moves from the aesthetic into the domain of shared life, where norms can only be established through mutual recognition and working things out together. What genuinely deserves criticism in saccharine photos must be identified in their relation to other everyday photographic practices, which is why I will bring in the snapshot as a point of contrast. From deskilled practices in the vein of Baldessari's Throwing Three Balls in the Air to Get a Straight Line to what Negri and Hardt call the "multitude," the snapshot disperses any unified image aesthetic. Saccharine photos do the opposite. They demand high skill, reproduce a centralized set of aesthetic norms in the name of "what the masses love to see," and do not encourage failure.
Lesson 08
How Do Taking Pictures and Photographs Change Memory?

"We take photographs to preserve memories" sounds self-evident, yet Roland Barthes said that the photograph quickly becomes a "counter-memory," and Geoffrey Batchen likewise asked whether photography has quietly replaced our memories with its own. To get to the bottom of this, we first have to set aside the metaphor of the brain as a storage device. Bartlett's repeated-reproduction experiments and the "observer perspective" in recollection both show that memory is a reconstruction carried out from the present. Deleuze, reading Proust, went further, arguing that the search for lost time is an apprenticeship, a long engagement with signs, and that it is oriented toward the future. With this background, Kracauer's wariness toward photographs becomes clear. A photograph indiscriminately records a spatial continuum, while memory retains only meaningful fragments. The photograph of a grandmother at twenty-four gradually turns into a display of old-fashioned costume, and the person's history is "buried as if under a layer of snow." At the end of the lecture, we will follow Batchen to look at photographic jewelry containing locks of hair, overpainted tintypes and Indian painted portraits, and ask what material transformations a photograph must undergo for looking at it to become, once again, a form of learning.
