Season 05

A Research Map of the Frontiers of Photography Theory

This season maps the main research paths of photography theory since the 1970s, moving from a methodological introduction and the theoretical foundations of power and knowledge to the social power model, critical deconstruction, sociology, liberal historicism, techno-media ontology, and post-critical theory. The course focuses on how different theories pose questions, what resources they draw on, and which photographic practices they can explain.

Season 5: A Research Map of the Frontiers of Photography Theory course poster

Lesson 01

Introduction I: Photography Theory Since the 1970s

Course slide cover for Photography Theory Since the 1970s
Season 5, Introduction I: course slides.

This introduction presents how the nine basic methods on the map above analyze photography. Over these fifty years, the development of photography theory has methodologically changed the basic premises of photography studies. As photographs have further become the medium of life itself, the task of photography theory has correspondingly shifted from interpreting the pictorial content of photographs to understanding how photographs take effect within society, history, and technology. By outlining the nine main methods that have gradually formed in photography theory over the past half century, along with their representative figures and ideas, this lesson considers what distinct paths photography theory has contributed to our understanding of photography today.

Lesson 02

Introduction II: Photography Theory Since the 1970s

Course slide cover for Photography Theory Since the 1970s
Season 5, Introduction II: course slides.

Photography theory after the 1970s is often read as though it were written in an impenetrable code, because it borrows heavily from the theoretical premises of philosophy and sociology, and these premises are often no longer explained in the works themselves. An author such as John Tagg assumes that his readers are already familiar with Foucault and Althusser, and it is easy for us to be stopped by the terminology before we have understood the problems it addresses. This lesson examines the two beliefs that the nine approaches outlined in the previous lesson all set themselves against: formalism and positivism. Drawing on Thierry de Duve's distinction between modernism and formalism, we will see that questioning the boundaries of a medium is one thing, and fixing those boundaries and using them to pass judgment on works is another; the debates provoked by Jon Rafman's video game screenshots and The Nine Eyes of Google Street View turn precisely on this divergence. And why have the transparency of the photograph and the self-sufficiency of its meaning, both articles of positivist faith, been persistently called into question by later theory? The change in meaning that the same portrait undergoes when it appears on a wanted poster and in an art book offers a way into this question. On this basis, I will explain Foucault's discourse and dispositif, Derrida's dismantling of binary oppositions, and Bourdieu's habitus and field, so that in the close readings that follow we can understand what each theory opposes, and the premises on which it analyzes photography.

Lesson 03

How Photography Became an Instrument of Power: Photography and the Social Power Model

Frontiers of Photography Theory course illustration
How photography becomes an instrument of power: diagram of photography and social power.

As the earliest wave of literature after the 1970s to challenge modernist and positivist beliefs, the work of John Tagg (major work: The Burden of Representation, available in Chinese translation), Allan Sekula, and others drew anew on the ideas of Michel Foucault, Louis Althusser, and others. They argued that photography is bound up with oppression not because some photographs depict violence or injustice, nor because photography is inherently oppressive, but because the production, classification, circulation, and use of photographic images are embedded from the outset in the workings of the state, capital, and institutions. This lesson introduces the basic views and premises of this model of photography and power, namely that photography as a social practice is understood as a technology of governance rather than a means of individual aesthetic expression.

Lesson 04

Photography as Language: Critical Deconstructionism

Frontiers of Photography Theory course illustration
Photography as language: diagram of critical deconstruction.

Rosalind Krauss's critique of photography is very important both for her own academic career and for the development of art-historical critical methods as a whole (major work: The Originality of the Avant-Garde and Other Modernist Myths, available in Chinese translation); she is also deeply connected with the next lesson. This lesson focuses on the earliest line within critical deconstructionism to take on photography: continuing the theoretical legacy of twentieth-century structuralism and post-structuralism, it treats photography as a language. Krauss's examination of Eugène Atget and Victor Burgin's critique of Stieglitz both seek to reveal the paradoxes of the various natural assumptions behind images.

Lesson 05

How Did Photography Become a Middle-Brow Art?

Frontiers of Photography Theory course illustration
How did photography become an art of middle-class taste? Diagram of theoretical approaches.

Bourdieu can in fact be counted among classic critics as renowned as Barthes and Benjamin. This lesson introduces what Bourdieu meant by "photography as a middle-brow art." In France in the 1960s and 1970s, photography had already become a widespread leisure activity, and for Bourdieu this was because it could offer a safe, respectable, controllable means of creation without challenging the cultural order—hence a "middle-brow" art. Following the line of how the everyday logic of photographic practice is internalized by a safe social structure, we will also touch on the latest developments in the sociological critical approach, such as Howard Becker and Paul Frosh.

Lesson 06

Desire and History: Liberal Historicism

Frontiers of Photography Theory course illustration
Desire and history: diagram of liberal historicism.

The liberal historicist approach is heavily influenced by French thought, and its representative figures are mostly French scholars, such as André Rouillé and Clément Chéroux. Rouillé's La Photographie: Entre document et art contemporain is available in Chinese translation. Beyond this, the lesson focuses on Geoffrey Batchen's new examination of photography's origins in Burning with Desire: The Conception of Photography, as an example of a refined liberal historicist method. Liberal historicism does not tend toward radical critique of photography, focusing instead on the recovery of historical sources and on the marginal and the diverse within history as it unfolds. Accordingly, Batchen questions the positivist belief about the origin of photography, treating it as an assemblage of cultural wishes and desires.

Lesson 07

Techno-Media Ontology and Nonhuman Photography

Frontiers of Photography Theory course illustration
Technical media ontology and nonhuman photography: diagram of theoretical approaches.

This lesson first introduces Ian Bogost's highly influential writings on photography in international scholarship. Against the background of his "alien phenomenology," speculative realism, and "object-oriented ontology" (OOO), Bogost treats photography as a medium that can reveal "ontography." Flusser (Into the Universe of Technical Images is available in Chinese translation) can be counted as a pioneer of techno-media ontology, but not a central figure of this method. Overall, the techno-media ontological method both overlaps with and differs from posthumanism. This method gradually breaks away from anthropocentric approaches, treating photography primarily as a generative technical practice and further examining how this technical practice changes the existing boundaries of our subjectivity. Zylinska and others, combining feminist awareness, try to explain why photography is fundamentally nonhuman and fluid; Rubinstein, by contrast, opposes the Cartesian centrism inherent in the Enlightenment perspective and explores photography's generative role with respect to the world.

Lesson 08

Post-Critical Theory: Photography and Possible Futures

Frontiers of Photography Theory course illustration
Postcritical theory: photography and possible futures, a diagram of theoretical approaches.

This lesson introduces the post-critical theory model, one of the newest theoretical developments since the new millennium. Its proponents are dissatisfied with the negative dismantling of photography by the power model and critical deconstructionism, and pay more attention to photography's constitutive role as a mechanism of witnessing and in building civil society and the rules of intersubjectivity. John Roberts, Ariella Aïsha Azoulay, and others on the one hand inherit the power model's critique of photography, and on the other are not content, as Sekula was, to focus only on dismantling and warning while building little; they therefore concentrate on uncovering the political potential behind the photographic medium, in an attempt to let the camera photograph a better future for us. We will explore how they understand photography as a relational medium linking private experience and the public world. Since Azoulay's thought was introduced in Season 2, this lesson will focus on the views of photography of John Roberts, Susie Linfield, and Margaret Iversen.

References

希尔达·凡·吉尔德、海伦·维斯特杰斯特. 摄影理论(历史脉络与案例分析)[M]. 中国民族摄影艺术出版社,2014.

亨利·列斐伏尔. 空间的生产[M]. 刘怀玉等,译. 商务印书馆,2021.

威廉·弗鲁塞尔. 摄影哲学的思考[M]. 毛卫东、丁君君,译. 中国民族摄影艺术出版社,2017.

汉娜·阿伦特. 人的境况[M]. 上海人民出版社,2009.

羅蘭·巴特. 神話學[M]. 許薔薔、許綺玲譯. 桂冠圖書,1997. 繁體中文版.

约翰·塔格. 表征的重负(论摄影与历史)[M]. 周韵,译. 重庆大学出版社,2018.

罗兰·巴特. 明室(摄影札记)[M]. 许绮玲,译. 和英出版社,1995. 繁体中文版.

蒂埃利·德·迪弗. 杜尚之后的康德[M]. 沈语冰、张晓剑、陶铮,译. 江苏美术出版社,2014.

路德维希·维特根斯坦. 哲学研究[M]. 陈嘉映,译. 上海人民出版社,2005.

米歇尔·福柯. 性经验史[M]. 佘碧平,译. 上海人民出版社,2016.

米歇尔·福柯. 规训与惩罚[M]. 刘北成、杨远婴,译. 生活·读书·新知三联书店.

雅克·德里达. 书写与差异[M]. 张宁,译. 中国人民大学出版社,2022.

罗莎琳·克劳斯. 前卫的原创性及其他现代主义神话[M]. 周文姬、路珏,译. 江苏凤凰美术出版社,2015.

雅克·德里达. 声音与现象[M]. 杜小真,译. 商务印书馆,2010.

乔纳森·克拉里. 知觉的悬置(注意力、景观与现代文化)[M]. 沈语冰、贺玉高,译. 江苏凤凰美术出版社,2017.

米歇尔·福柯. 知识考古学[M]. 董树宝,译. 生活·读书·新知三联书店,2021. 第 4 版.

乔弗里·巴钦. 热切的渴望:摄影概念的诞生[M]. 毛卫东,译. 中国民族摄影艺术出版社,2016.

康德. 康德著作全集(第 05 卷 实践理性批判、判断力批判)[M]. 李秋零主编、译. 中国人民大学出版社,2007.

安德烈·胡耶. 摄影(从文献到当代艺术)[M]. 袁燕舞,译. 浙江摄影出版社,2018.

乔纳森·克拉里. 观察者的技术(论十九世纪的视觉与现代性)[M]. 蔡佩君,译. 华东师范大学出版社,2017.

马丁·杰伊. 低垂之眼(20 世纪法国思想对视觉的贬损)[M]. 孔锐才,译. 重庆大学出版社,2021.

罗西·布拉伊多蒂. 后人类[M]. 宋根成,译. 河南大学出版社,2016.

苏珊·桑塔格. 旁观他人之痛苦[M]. 陈耀成,译. 麦田出版,2014. 第 2 版·繁体中文版.

Azoulay, Ariella. Civil Imagination: A Political Ontology of Photography. Translated by Louise Bethlehem, Verso, 2024, paperback edition.

Azoulay, Ariella. The Civil Contract of Photography. Zone Books, 2008.

Azoulay, Ariella Aïsha. Potential History: Unlearning Imperialism. Verso, 2019.

Barthes, Roland. Rhetoric of the Image. English Excerpt.

Barthes, Roland. Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1981.

Brown, Elspeth H., and Thy Phu, editors. Feeling Photography. Duke University Press, 2014.

Elkins, James. What Photography Is. Routledge, 2011.

Flusser, Vilém. Towards a Philosophy of Photography. Reaktion Books, 2000.

Freund, Gisèle. Photography and Society. David R. Godine, 1980.

Fried, Michael. Why Photography Matters as Art as Never Before. Yale University Press, 2008.

Frosh, Paul. The Image Factory: Consumer Culture, Photography and the Visual Content Industry. Berg, 2003.

Gernsheim, Helmut. A Concise History of Photography. Dover Publications, 1986.

Guindi, Fadwa El. Visual Anthropology: Essential Method and Theory. AltaMira Press, 2004.

Krauss, Rosalind E. The Originality of the Avant-Garde and Other Modernist Myths. MIT Press, 1986, paperback edition.

Leeker, Martina, Imanuel Schipper, and Timon Beyes, editors. Performing the Digital. transcript Verlag, 2017.

Linfield, Susie. The Cruel Radiance: Photography and Political Violence. University of Chicago Press, 2010.

Neumüller, Moritz, editor. The Routledge Companion to Photography, Representation and Social Justice. Routledge, 2022.

Phillips, Christopher. “The Judgment Seat of Photography.” October 22, 1982, pp. 27–63.

Roberts, John. Art and Emancipation. Brill, 2024.

Roberts, John. The Art of Interruption: Realism, Photography and the Everyday. Manchester University Press, 1998.

Roberts, John. Revolutionary Time and the Avant-Garde. Verso, 2015.

Roberts, John. “Unfitting: Art and Labour from Conceptualisation to AI.” The Nordic Journal of Aesthetics 33(67), 2024.

Sekula, Allan. “The Body and the Archive.” October 39, 1986, pp. 3–64.

Sekula, Allan. Photography Between Labour and Capital. 1983.

Sekula, Allan. Photography against the Grain: Essays and Photo Works 1973–1983. Press of the Nova Scotia College of Art and Design, 1984.

Sontag, Susan. On Photography. Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1977.

Zylinska, Joanna. Nonhuman Photography. MIT Press, 2017.

Zylinska, Joanna. The Perception Machine. MIT Press, 2023.

Bourdieu, Pierre, et al. Photography: A Middle-Brow Art. Translated by Shaun Whiteside, Polity Press, 1990.

Instructor