Lesson 01
Allan Sekula, "The Instrumental Image: Steichen at War"

Allan Sekula worked across photographic practice, art history and criticism, and the question he kept returning to was the social function of photography. This lecture examines his 1975 essay "The Instrumental Image: Steichen at War" through two key terms: realism and reference. A photograph comes from the world it depicts, and through viewing and circulation it acts back upon that world. The critical realism Sekula defended is the conscious mastery of this two-way relationship. By the 1970s, however, the documentary tradition of the 1920s and 1930s had been broken. Walker Evans's "documentary style" had stripped documentary photography of its social function. Totalitarian politics had stigmatized realism. Abstract Expressionism had been enlisted as ideological propaganda in the Cold War. Conceptual art had then hollowed out the photograph's referentiality, turning it into a game of the artist's ideas. Only against this background can we understand why Sekula condemned Edward Steichen so completely. We will begin with aerial reconnaissance photographs from the First World War. We will see how the camera became a component in a trinity of transport, communication and destruction, and how the photograph was confined by "mechanical reading" to a single referent. We will then consider how, when these photographs entered military museums and the art market after the war, discourses of abstraction, aestheticization and humanism washed away their violence. Following Steichen's career from military work through commercial photography to The Family of Man, Sekula argues that the man the Museum of Modern Art celebrated for winning photography's independence had produced instrumental images all along.
Lesson 02
Ariella Aïsha Azoulay: Undoing Photography's Imperial Rights

Ariella Aïsha Azoulay opens her essay with a proposition. What would it mean if photography originated not with the invention of the apparatus in 1839, but in 1492, when Columbus reached the Americas and empire began to take shape? This seemingly outlandish backdating targets the habitual logic of how we narrate the relationship between photography and colonialism: first there was empire, and only later was photography, a neutral technology, taken up as its tool. Azoulay argues that the shutter's operation is structurally identical to the violence of empire. The shutter cuts fragments out of continuous time and space, then names, appropriates and transforms them. Empire likewise destroys existing worlds and replaces them with new classifications and meanings. Through the British Indian project The People of India, we will see how the same bamboo staff could be read as a weapon or as useful material, depending on the needs of colonial rule. We will also discuss how imperial modes of seeing enshrine the photographer as the sole source of meaning and fix the photographed as identifiable, consumable labels. If Sekula in the previous lecture concentrated on dismantling, Azoulay offers a constructive approach. Its elements are unlearning, potential history, and a reconception of the photograph not as finished evidence but as a never-ending photographic event. Daguerreotypes of Renty have been held in Harvard's archives for more than 170 years, and his descendant Tamara Lanier has sued Harvard over them. This case will give concrete form to two concepts: "the citizenry of photography" and "the civil contract." For Azoulay, photographs record the violence of empire, and for that very reason they retain the potential to demand repair.

Lesson 03
James Elkins, *What Photography Is*

James Elkins's What Photography Is is a book written explicitly in response to Roland Barthes's Camera Lucida. Camera Lucida begins in mourning for Barthes's mother, and its prose is highly literary. Yet when scholars cite it, they tend to extract only concepts such as the studium and the punctum, sweeping away Barthes's writing on time, loss and death. Elkins therefore asks: if we no longer center humanist feeling and meaning, what is left of photography? He first dismantles the optical model that treats the photograph as a transparent window or a faithful mirror. Even the "camera lucida" that Barthes set against the camera obscura is, in Elkins's view, too bright and too successful. He then assembles a set of "failed windows": selenite windowpanes, black ice on a lake, and a photograph of bacteria whose subject cannot be seen at all. Together they remind us that the photograph's material surface cannot easily be penetrated by the gaze. I will focus on what he calls the "surroundings": the unintended, often unwanted things that occupy most of the picture. In the portrait of Lewis Payne, where Barthes read a tragic fate, Elkins sees rivets, seams and scratches on the hull of an ironclad. He argues that looking only at the face is itself a way of not looking. Dullness, the inhuman and pain thus become his points of entry into the question of what photography is. Finally, I will compare Elkins with Alain Robbe-Grillet's theory of the novel. Both seek to strip away the layer of meaning that people impose on the world and to turn toward the world of things. Why could this project succeed in photography, when in Robbe-Grillet's novels it largely failed?
Lesson 04
Douglas Crimp, *On the Museum's Ruins*

Douglas Crimp can be considered a representative figure of October, and his book On the Museum's Ruins ought to be regarded as a book about photography. In 1977 at Artists Space in New York, Crimp curated the exhibition "Pictures," which defined the artists of the "Pictures Generation." Most of these photographers are still household names today. In this lesson, we will explain how photography, after reaching the 1970s, challenged and dismantled the aesthetic discourse on which modernism rested and its core institution—the art museum. Returning to the historical scene of the 1970s, to this crucial, decisive turning point in the history of photography, we will follow Crimp in examining the historical price paid for bringing photography into the museum.
Lesson 05
Abigail Solomon-Godeau, "Harry Callahan: Gender, Genre, and Street Photography"

This essay comes from Abigail Solomon-Godeau's signature book Photography After Photography, and is also the short piece I think most fully embodies her main positions and problematic. Usually, "street photography" is regarded as a self-evident photographic "genre," but Solomon-Godeau questions from a gender perspective how much of importance this natural classification obscures. By analyzing the female subjects in Harry Callahan's photographs, we will explain how Solomon-Godeau reveals the gender-political structure in such photographic works that take women as the primary object of the gaze; and how she reveals that a formalist critical discourse appealing to the "universal" rather than to "difference" ends up as an ideological strategy that obscures social meaning. This essay is relatively complex and difficult, so Chinese translations of key passages or a draft translation of the full text will be provided.
Lesson 06
Christopher Pinney, *Camera Indica: The Social Life of Indian Photographs*

This is the first time in our six seasons that we cover ideas of photography from anthropology, and the only time we touch on photography in a postcolonial context. Christopher Pinney's Camera Indica (the title itself parodies Roland Barthes's Camera Lucida) is one of the landmark works on photography in anthropology, and conversely one of the representative anthropological works in photography studies. During fieldwork, Pinney observed a huge difference in value between what he considered a "good" photograph and what local people considered a "good" photograph. From this, we will explain: why did a photographic technology originating in the West have such a different "social life" in India? Further, how was the camera, originally a colonial tool, absorbed and transformed in the activities of indigenous Indian culture? We will use concepts such as inter-ocularity to explain the complex field of interaction that Pinney uncovered, in which photographic images, religious stone sculpture, chromolithographs, film posters, and other visual experiences permeate one another; this is also a critique of Western modernism's typical demand for the purity of "medium specificity."
Lesson 07
Susie Linfield, *The Cruel Radiance: Photography and Political Violence*

This book has greatly influenced my own academic views on photography; it was also a finalist for the 2010 National Book Critics Circle Award and won several best book awards. Starting from images of violence and suffering, Linfield goes straight to the predicament of current left-wing criticism: as some left-wing critics persistently warn viewers to beware of photography's aestheticization of suffering, of photography numbing its viewers, and of photography being used by power, have these arguments by now become an ethical evasion and an intellectual self-limitation? That is—when images of suffering are dismissed with "one should not look" or "one should not photograph," is this really to protect the dignity of victims, or so that the viewers' own moral conscience can remain free of reproach? Linfield thus reflects on the skepticism that dominates contemporary photography criticism, trying to help us trust again photography's capacity to connect us with the suffering of distant people, and affirming photography's role in building a discursive consensus on "human rights." We will explain how Linfield, through one photographic controversy after another, seeks to defend photography's rights and to rebuild an ethics of looking and a politics of emotion.
Lesson 08
Hito Steyerl, *Medium Hot*

Hito Steyerl's Medium Hot places AI images back within the social and material conditions that sustain their production. When we ask whether AI is creative, or whether generated images count as art, energy consumption, the appropriation of datasets and the labor of annotators are usually left out of the discussion. Steyerl calls AI outputs "statistical renderings." The term stresses the difference between their probabilistic basis and the physical causality of photographic indexicality. Through the notion of the "mean image," she examines how biases already present in datasets are repeated and condensed. She further argues that producing order at the level of information comes at the cost of energy consumption and rising entropy in the physical world. Understanding these images therefore requires a shift from an optical paradigm to a thermodynamic one. This lecture reorganizes the book's ten essays into several sets of interrelated questions. Following the thread of "autonomy," it traces the connections among machines, capital, autonomous weapons and creative labor. I will also discuss the limits of this critique. How much explanatory power does the language of thermodynamics actually add? Does the recursive protest she proposes hold up under the conditions in which data annotators in Uganda can actually organize and act? These disagreements bear on how we move from a critique of images to an understanding of their conditions of production, and to changing them.

