Season 07

How Contemporary Photography Engages Reality

From British social documentary, Paul Graham, and Thomas Ruff to Jeff Wall, Wolfgang Tillmans, and Forensic Architecture, this season asks how photography becomes a way of understanding the world. Starting from specific images and working methods, the course discusses the connections among a photograph's form, the experience of viewing, and its efficacy in reality.

Season 7: How Contemporary Photography Engages Reality course poster

Lesson 01

From Changing Life to Understanding Life: The Transformation of British Social Documentary Photography

How Contemporary Photography Engages with Reality course illustration
Paul Graham, Turf Lodge, Belfast, 1984

Compared with the American social documentary tradition we know well (represented by Walker Evans, Dorothea Lange, and others), British social documentary photography, which emerged after the 1970s, absorbed the legacy of the former yet took a path completely different from contemporaneous American social documentary. To clarify the forces behind this turn, we need to explore at least three levels: first, the crisis documentary photography faced as a medium in the 1970s; second, the modernist institutionalization and autonomization of American documentary photography; and third, the new form of social subject shaped by British neoliberal governmentality (what I have previously called the duality of "the victim is also the perpetrator"). Rather than simply introducing what British documentary photography "is," I am more concerned with "why" it became this way—that is, how British social documentary photography accomplished a sociological transformation of its modernist form. On this basis, I will lead you into Paul Graham's color documentary practice. I will also discuss the work of the recently deceased Martin Parr, in his memory.

Lesson 02

The Tradition of Landscape Photography: The Indifference and Emptiness of Visual Language

How Contemporary Photography Engages with Reality course illustration
Robert Adams, Pikes Peak, Colorado Springs, 1969 gelatin silver print image: 14 x 14.9 cm (5 1/2 x 5 7/8 in.) Private collection, San Francisco.

I thought about this topic for a long time. My original intention was to address a few questions: Why has the visual language of contemporary landscape photography become ever cooler and more detached? How did this seemingly desolate, indifferent landscape photography become the mainstream of contemporary landscape photography? What role does it actually play in helping us understand the world we live in today? By now I have worked out a preliminary answer. Rosalind Krauss long ago discussed O'Sullivan's photography, and landscape photography from that time already displayed its indifferent visual appearance. The culmination of this indifferent appearance is undoubtedly wilderness photography. And "wilderness" is in fact a visual category that connects back to the European tradition of landscape painting, and even to "landscape" itself. Therefore, this lesson will start from the origins of landscape photography, analyzing its medium-specific characteristics as a particular genre, and then use the works of Carleton Watkins, Timothy O'Sullivan, Ansel Adams, Robert Adams, Ed Ruscha, and Andreas Gursky to explain the causes, evolution, and efficacy of this rather detached visual form in contemporary landscape photography.

Lesson 03

Thomas Ruff: The Hauntology of the Photographic Archive and the Afterlife of Images

How Contemporary Photography Engages with Reality course illustration
jpeg bb03, Thomas Ruff, F-RUFF-1F08.22, 2007, C-print with Diasec, 72 7/8 x 98 1/4 in. (185.1 x 249.56 cm)

My systematic thinking about Ruff grew out of conversations with him at this year's Lishui Photography Festival. Ruff is often defined as an explorer of the photographic medium, and this is of course the mainstream approach. Yet this approach still cannot settle a question for me: what makes Ruff's images "worth looking at"? In other words, a photographer's contribution to the evolution of the medium cannot explain the unique power of his work to move us: there are so many photographers devoted to interrogating the boundaries of the photographic medium—why Ruff in particular? How does Ruff differ from other artists equally concerned with questions of the medium? What I try to do is to begin from his archival method, analyzing how the sensible qualities of his images are constituted, and thereby explain the source of the distinctive power of Ruff's work. I will place Ruff's images within the lineage of "afterlife" (Nachleben) associated with Walter Benjamin, Aby Warburg, and Jacques Derrida, and use the "archive" as another axis to locate and interpret Thomas Ruff's practice. In an earlier course I interpreted his signature Portraits series mainly from the perspective of the "archive," focusing on how Ruff addressed the question of the archive through concrete practice; this time I want to offer a more holistic interpretation of Ruff's method and its results, to explain our experience of viewing his work. Specifically, I will start from the Stars series of his early career and focus on the jpegs, tableaux chinois, and other portraits series, to explain why Ruff's images are distinctive and what kind of distinctiveness they have.

Lesson 04

Jeff Wall: Writing and Depiction

Jeff Wall, A Sudden Gust of Wind (after Hokusai), 1993.
Jeff Wall, A Sudden Gust of Wind (after Hokusai), 1993.

Why do Jeff Wall's works have such a strongly painterly character? Merely recognizing that he appropriates Manet or Velázquez still cannot explain why these photographs matter. Wall's practice began at the height of Conceptual art, and his early Landscape Manual also subordinated photographs to text. Thereafter, however, he returned to carefully constructed scenes and to the sensuous power of the image itself to move us. I will approach this turn through the relationship between two orientations, "writing" and "depiction." The former involves Conceptual art's legacy of deskilling and of intervening in the spectacle through intellectual critique; the latter involves the tradition, running since the Renaissance, of creating self-sufficient worlds through composition, perspective and the arrangement of scenes. How does Wall accept the critical force of the former while restoring the latter's capacity for sensuous communication with the viewer? This lecture takes The Destroyed Room as its point of entry, analyzing its relationship to Delacroix's The Death of Sardanapalus, and then turns to Duchamp's Étant donnés to discuss the position of the voyeur, interior lighting, and the constructedness of the scene. Through this, I want to show how Wall treats earlier works as models to be studied and reconstructed, so that viewers, even as they enter the world of the image, can also become aware of how that world has been built.

Lesson 05

Jeff Wall: Cinematographic Photography and Near Documentary

Jeff Wall, Milk, 1984.
Jeff Wall, Milk, 1984.

Why can a photograph meticulously constructed on a set still be called "near documentary"? The previous lecture discussed how Wall redeploys painting's tradition of the staged scene; this lecture goes further, to explain what kind of relationship this working method actually establishes with modern life. I will begin with Milk, setting Wall's film-based casting, set construction and staging against the aesthetics of the instant that Szarkowski established in The Photographer's Eye. The key to near documentary lies in the interval of time between encountering an event and reconstructing it. This interval allows bodily experience to be reanalyzed and reorganized, and it also leaves room for the construction of allusion and form. The behind-the-scenes outtakes for The Listener, along with Movie Audience, will help us understand how such construction changes bodily gesture and unfolds a narrative world beyond the frame within a still image. I will then draw on Deleuze's distinction between "privileged instants" and the "any-instant-whatever," as well as Wall's own notions of "dry intelligence" and "liquid intelligence," to analyze the relationship between extreme control and the uncontrolled flow of liquid in Milk. Following this thread, we will return to Manet's legacy as the "painter of modern life," explaining why Wall seeks to carry this tradition forward through photography, and why the lightbox, an advertising device, also forms part of his practice.

Lesson 06

Wolfgang Tillmans: Fragile, Precarious Life

How Contemporary Photography Engages with Reality course illustration
Installation view of the exhibition "Wolfgang Tillmans: To look without fear"

I used to understand Wolfgang Tillmans in very stereotyped terms, seeing him as merely a photographer who made it his mission to capture fragments of subcultural youth life. Yet this understanding cannot explain a core contradiction: why do his seemingly casual, even "anti-technical" images produce in the museum a sense of pressure that is both highly engaging and rigorous? More importantly, Tillmans's photographs change the way we perceive the world: after viewing his images, we start to recognize Tillmans-like moments in real life too. That is also why his photography has become so popular around the world. He is the kind of artist whose work makes you want to pick up a camera yourself. Later I realized that for Tillmans, there is no meaning of the single photograph, or rather the meaning of a single work cannot be self-sufficient. The only work is "the exhibition as medium" itself. So in this lesson I try to argue that Tillmans's real contribution lies in breaking photographic modernism's binary oppositions between abstract and figurative, high and low. I will analyze how he breaks the museum's traditional linear narrative and aesthetic hierarchy through means such as taping prints directly to the wall and mixing huge inkjet prints with postcard-sized images. The gaps between images, their placement higher or lower, their size—none of these is trivial. Together they form a dynamic semantic network that compels viewers to draw on their own pre-understanding, wander through it, and produce meaning.

Lesson 07

Forensic Architecture: Investigative Aesthetics and the Politics of Truth

How Contemporary Photography Engages with Reality course illustration
Forensis, Forensic Architecture in collaboration with SITU Research, DRONE STRIKES: UNMANNED AERIAL VIOLENCE | “The Architecture of Memory.” A drone survivor building a computer model of her home to enhance her memory in Mir Ali, North Waziristan, destroyed on October 4th 2010., Visualization: © Forensic Architecture and SITU Research

If we accept that since the advent of digital photography (to say nothing of AI today), photography has been moving toward a "post-truth" era, we have to face the question: does the traditional logic of documentary photography based on "bearing witness in person" still hold full efficacy in this era? As the truth of events increasingly depends on what Hito Steyerl calls the "politics of truth," how should those who use photography dig up, once again through photography, truths buried by various means? As the finale of the whole season, I will focus on the artistic practice of Forensic Architecture, a group much in demand in visual culture studies and contemporary art, and analyze their concrete practice from the perspective of "counter-forensics" (proposed by our bootcamp's "old acquaintance" Allan Sekula, referring to a political practice of evidence-gathering). For example, how did they analyze the pixels of smoke spreading at an explosion site to infer the specific type of bomb and its trajectory, thereby exposing an official denial of an attack as a lie? And this new paradigm of evidence, grounded in the constructive nature of forensics (the Latin root of "forensic" originally referred to "the public forum"), has in turn promoted a forensic aesthetics—a gloomier humanism: going deep into concrete traces of bones, fragments, and images for careful excavation and identification. And this is where photography is irreplaceable: photography has political efficacy here precisely because of its weakness in the capacity for abstraction.

References

尤尔根·哈贝马斯. 公共领域的结构转型[M]. 学林出版社,1999.

约翰·塔格. 表征的重负(论摄影与历史)[M]. 周韵,译. 重庆大学出版社,2018.

约翰·萨考斯基. 摄影师之眼[M]. 唐凌洁,译. 人民邮电出版社,2012.

雷蒙德·威廉斯. 马克思主义与文学[M]. 王尔勃、周莉,译. 河南大学出版社,2008.

雅克·德里达. 赠予死亡[M]. 王钦,译. 西北大学出版社,2018.

克莱门特·格林伯格. 现代主义绘画(附导读)[M]. 沈语冰,译. 北京师范大学出版社,2010. 第 259–276 页. 节选.

波德莱尔. 波德莱尔美学论文选[M]. 郭宏安,译. 人民文学出版社,1987.

蒂埃利·德·迪弗. 杜尚之后的康德[M]. 沈语冰、张晓剑、陶铮,译. 江苏美术出版社,2014.

列维纳斯. 总体与无限(论外在性)[M]. 朱刚,译. 北京大学出版社,2016.

吉尔·德勒兹. 电影 I(运动-影像)[M]. 远流出版,2003. 繁体中文版.

吉尔·德勒兹. 运动·影像[M]. 谢强、马月,译. 湖南美术出版社,2016.

姜宇辉. 后人类影像(探索一种后德勒兹的电影哲学)[M]. 上海人民出版社,2024.

朱迪斯·巴特勒. 脆弱不安的生命(哀悼与暴力的力量)[M]. 何磊、赵英男,译. 河南大学出版社,2016. 第 2 版.

Armstrong, Nancy. Fiction in the Age of Photography: The Legacy of British Realism. Harvard University Press.

Ault, Julie, et al. Wolfgang Tillmans. Yale University Press, 2006.

Becker, Tobias, and Dylan Trigg, editors. The Routledge Handbook of Nostalgia. Routledge, 2025.

Bogue, Ronald. Deleuze on Cinema. Routledge, 2003.

Bordo, Jonathan. Picture and Witness at the Site of Wilderness.

Bright, Susan. Art Photography Now. Aperture, 2005.

Burgin, Victor. The End of Art Theory: Criticism and Postmodernity. Macmillan, 1986.

Campany, David. Jeff Wall: Picture for Women. Afterall Books, 2011.

Chandler, David. A Thing There Was That Mattered: Paul Graham: Photographs 1981–2006. English Transcript.

Christov-Bakargiev, Carolyn. “Thomas Ruff at the End of the Photographic Dream.” Skira, 2009, pp. 12–23.

Davis, Colin. Hauntology, Spectres and Phantoms.

de Duve, Thierry, et al. Jeff Wall. Phaidon Press, 1996.

Dercon, Chris, Helen Sainsbury, and Wolfgang Tillmans, editors. Wolfgang Tillmans 2017. Tate Publishing, 2017.

Derrida, Jacques. Specters of Marx: The State of the Debt, the Work of Mourning and the New International. Translated by Peggy Kamuf, Routledge, 2006.

Fisher, Mark. “What Is Hauntology.” Film Quarterly 66(1), 2012, pp. 16–24.

Forensic Architecture. Forensis: The Architecture of Public Truth. Sternberg Press, 2014.

Forster, Laurel, and Sue Harper, editors. British Culture and Society in the 1970s: The Lost Decade. Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2010.

Fried, Michael. Why Photography Matters as Art as Never Before. Yale University Press, 2008.

Fuller, Matthew, and Eyal Weizman. Investigative Aesthetics: Conflicts and Commons in the Politics of Truth. Verso, 2021.

Graham, Paul. Photographs 1981-2006. SteidlMACK.

Hill, Paul, et al. Three Perspectives on Photography: Recent British Photography. Arts Council of Great Britain, 1979.

Hutchinson, Wesley. “The Northern Ireland Troubles: What Was There to Photograph.” Przegląd Kulturoznawczy 3(37), 2018, pp. 365–380.

Hägglund, Martin. Radical Atheism: Derrida and the Time of Life. Stanford University Press, 2008.

Jones, Andrew Wyn. The British Experience with American Independent Photography, 1944-1980. University of Texas at Austin, 2014, PhD dissertation.

Keenan, Thomas. “Counter-forensics and Photography.” Grey Room 55, 2014, pp. 58–77.

Kismaric, Susan. British Photography from the Thatcher Years. Museum of Modern Art, 1990.

Krauss, Rosalind E. The Originality of the Avant-Garde and Other Modernist Myths. MIT Press, 1986, paperback edition.

Kuo, Michelle. “Step into Liquid: The Ascendancy of Ink-Jet Printing.” Artforum 51(1), 2012.

Lewis, Tom. “The Politics of Hauntology in Derridas Specters of Marx.” Rethinking Marxism.

Martin, Stewart. “Wall’s Tableau Mort.” Oxford Art Journal 30(1), 2007, pp. 119–133.

Merritt, Naomi. Jeff Wall and the Concept of the Picture. Routledge, 2021.

Mulvey, Laura. “A Sudden Gust of Wind (after Hokusai): From After to Before the Photograph.” Oxford Art Journal 30(1), 2007, pp. 27–37.

Nancy, Jean-Luc. The Ground of the Image. Translated by Jeff Fort, Fordham University Press, 2005.

Obrist, Hans Ulrich, and Wolfgang Tillmans. The Conversation Series 6: Wolfgang Tillmans. Walther König, 2007.

Photography Workshop. Photography/Politics One. 5 x 7 Editions.

Roberts, John. The Art of Interruption: Realism, Photography and the Everyday. Manchester University Press, 1998.

Ruff, Thomas. Works 1979–2011. Essays by Okwui Enwezor et al., Schirmer Mosel, 2012.

Sekula, Allan. “The Body and the Archive.” October 39, 1986, pp. 3–64.

Sergio, Matilde. “Aby Warburg, Walter Benjamin, and the Memory of Images.” La Rivista di Engramma 191, 2022.

Spector, Jack J. Delacroix: The Death of Sardanapalus. Allen Lane, 1974.

Tillmans, Wolfgang, and Burkhard Riemschneider. Wolfgang Tillmans: Photo & Sexy Books.

Wall, Jeff. Selected Essays and Interviews. Museum of Modern Art, 2007.

Wall, Jeff. Photographs. Walther König, 2003.

Wall, Jeff, and John Roberts. “Post-60s Photography and Its Modernist Context: A Conversation.” Oxford Art Journal 30(1), 2007, pp. 153–167.

Weidner, Daniel. “Fort-, Über-, Nachleben: Zu einer Denkfigur bei Benjamin.” Benjamin-Studien 2, 2011, pp. 161–178.

Weidner, Daniel. “Life After Life: A Figure of Thought in Walter Benjamin.” Journal for Cultural and Religious Theory 19(3), 2020, pp. 463–475.

Weizman, Eyal. Forensic Architecture: Violence at the Threshold of Detectability. Zone Books, 2017.

Wilson, Andrew, et al. Paul Graham. Phaidon, 1996.

Instructor